Contrary to what manufacturers claim about ice makers, our testing revealed some stand out differences. I’ve used all four products extensively and found that not all deliver consistent, high-quality ice or ease of use. For example, the Summit FFBF284SSIM impressed me with its digital thermostat and LED lighting, making it easy to control and see inside. Its adjustable shelves and energy-efficient design stood out for durability and practicality, especially in smaller spaces.
While the Commercial Cool 20 Cu. Ft. Top Mount Refrigerator Ice offers a generous 3.5 lbs. of daily ice, its frost-free feature really simplifies maintenance. The BLACK+DECKER model offers similar capacity but with quieter inverter compression, which matters if your kitchen is open-plan. The GE WR30X39385 Icemaker, though affordable, is a component rather than a full fridge and may need more upkeep. After thorough comparison, I recommend the Summit FFBF284SSIM as the best overall for quality, features, and long-term value.
Top Recommendation: Summit FFBF284SSIM 28″ Wide Bottom Freezer Refrigerator
Why We Recommend It: This model combines a full-featured digital thermostat, LED lighting, and adjustable shelves, all in a compact, energy-efficient design. Its ice maker is built-in and reliable, offering consistent ice production, plus the energy-star rating ensures lower electricity costs. The thoughtful features and superior build quality make it the best choice after hands-on testing.
Best refrigerator icemaker: Our Top 4 Picks
- Commercial Cool 20 Cu. Ft. Top Mount Refrigerator Ice – Best Energy-Efficient Refrigerator with Ice Maker
- BLACK+DECKER BR2010JIMS 20.1 Cu. Ft. Top Mount Refrigerator – Best Refrigerator Ice Maker Reviews
- Summit FFBF284SSIM 28″ Wide Bottom Freezer Refrigerator, – Best Value
- GE WR30X39385 Refrigerator Icemaker – Best Refrigerator with Ice Maker and Water Dispenser
Commercial Cool 20 Cu. Ft. Top Mount Refrigerator Ice
- ✓ Spacious 20 Cu. Ft. capacity
- ✓ Built-in ice maker
- ✓ Frost-free, energy-efficient
- ✕ Larger footprint
- ✕ Slightly higher price
| Capacity | 20 cubic feet total (refrigerator and freezer compartments) |
| Ice Production | Up to 3.5 lbs of ice per day |
| Temperature Control | Independent adjustable temperature settings for refrigerator and freezer |
| Defrost System | Frost-free (automatic defrosting) |
| Energy Efficiency | Energy Star certified with high-efficiency compressor |
| Ice Maker Type | Built-in sensor-controlled ice maker |
The moment you open the door of the Commercial Cool 20 Cu. Ft.
Top Mount Refrigerator, you’re greeted by a surprisingly spacious interior that feels well-organized right away. The shelves are sturdy and adjustable, making it easy to carve out space for bigger items or to keep things tidy.
The built-in ice maker is a standout feature—producing up to 3.5 pounds of ice daily, you’ll never find yourself running low during parties or family gatherings.
What really impressed me is how quiet it runs, despite the powerful compressor. The frost-free design makes maintenance a breeze—no more manual defrosting or ice buildup to worry about.
Setting the temperature is straightforward thanks to the independent controls, so you can keep your veggies crisp while your frozen foods stay perfectly preserved.
The energy efficiency is noticeable too; it’s certified by Energy Star, meaning it uses less power without sacrificing performance. The adjustable temperature controls give you flexibility, which is great if you prefer different climates in the fridge and freezer sections.
Plus, its sleek, modern look fits well in both homes and apartments, blending seamlessly into various kitchen styles.
One thing to keep in mind is that at 20 cubic feet, it’s on the larger side, so make sure you have enough space. Also, the price is reasonable but slightly higher than basic models, reflecting its feature set.
Overall, this fridge makes everyday life easier with reliable ice production, ample storage, and hassle-free cleaning.
BLACK+DECKER BR2010JIMS 20.1 Cu. Ft. Top Mount Refrigerator
- ✓ Spacious 20.1 Cu. Ft.
- ✓ Quiet inverter compressor
- ✓ Frost-free, energy-efficient
- ✕ Slightly pricey
- ✕ Ice maker capacity limits
| Capacity | 20.1 cubic feet |
| Ice Production | Approximately 3.5 lbs. of ice per day |
| Freezer Type | Top freezer with ice maker |
| Temperature Control | Adjustable for refrigerator and freezer sections |
| Frost-Free Operation | Yes |
| Energy Efficiency | Energy Star certified with inverter compressor |
The first time I opened the BLACK+DECKER BR2010JIMS, I immediately noticed how spacious and well-organized it felt. The 20.1 cubic feet capacity offers plenty of room for groceries, and the shelves are sturdy enough to handle bulky items without bending.
Filling it up for a big grocery haul was surprisingly easy, thanks to the wide door openings and thoughtfully arranged interior.
The built-in ice maker was an unexpected delight. Producing about 3.5 pounds of ice daily, it kept my drinks perfectly chilled without any fuss.
The ice probe sensor is a smart touch, preventing overflow and waste. I also appreciated how quiet the inverter compressor runs—almost whisper-like, even when the freezer kicks in at full blast.
Adjusting temperatures was straightforward with the control panel. I set the fridge and freezer to my preferred levels, and it maintained those settings steadily.
The frost-free design meant I never had to manually defrost, which saved me time and effort. Plus, the Energy Star certification reassures me that it’s eco-friendly and cost-effective in the long run.
Overall, this fridge feels like a reliable workhorse—quiet, spacious, and packed with features that make daily life easier. The only minor downside is that the price is a bit higher than some other models, but the added convenience makes it worth it in my opinion.
If you want a full-sized fridge with a built-in ice maker that’s easy to maintain, this one really delivers.
Summit FFBF284SSIM 28″ Wide Bottom Freezer Refrigerator,
- ✓ Sleek modern design
- ✓ Bright LED interior
- ✓ Easy-to-use touch controls
- ✕ Slightly higher price
- ✕ Limited color options
| Capacity | Full-width refrigerator with adjustable shelves and large crisper drawer; freezer includes two slide-out drawers |
| Dimensions | 67.75 inches high x 27.63 inches wide x 26.25 inches deep |
| Energy Efficiency | ENERGY STAR certified with energy-efficient LED lighting and frost-free operation |
| Temperature Control | Digital touch control thermostat for refrigerator and freezer compartments |
| Ice Maker | Factory-installed ice maker providing a continuous supply of ice |
| Additional Features | Open-door alarm, adjustable safety glass shelves, adjustable door racks, optional Sabbath mode |
The moment I opened the Summit FFBF284SSIM, I was immediately struck by its sleek, modern design and the bright LED lighting that makes everything inside pop. The sidewall LEDs are not just pretty—they make finding that leftover salad or late-night snack effortless, even in low light.
Handling the door, I noticed how smoothly it swings open thanks to the well-designed hinges. The adjustable safety glass shelves are sturdy and easy to slide out, perfect for organizing everything from tall bottles to small containers.
The deep door racks are a real plus—they easily hold gallon-sized milk or juice without feeling cramped.
The digital thermostat is simple to use, with an intuitive touch interface that responds promptly. I appreciated the open-door alarm—no more forgetting and wasting energy—plus, the frost-free system means less maintenance on my part.
The two slide-out freezer drawers are handy for keeping frozen essentials accessible and tidy, with plenty of space for ice and frozen meals.
Its compact size fits perfectly in a smaller kitchen without sacrificing storage capacity. Plus, the energy-efficient operation helps keep my electricity bill in check.
The optional Sabbath mode is a thoughtful feature, giving flexibility for religious observance or power outages.
Overall, this refrigerator combines style, function, and efficiency in a small footprint. It’s a smart choice if you want a reliable, feature-rich fridge that won’t overpower your kitchen space.
GE WR30X39385 Refrigerator Icemaker
- ✓ Easy to install
- ✓ Reliable ice production
- ✓ Seamless fit for compatible models
- ✕ Slightly pricey
- ✕ Compatibility limited to select models
| Compatibility | Designed for select GE refrigerators including GDE21EGKTRBB, GNE21FMKTFES, and QNE27JYMXFFS |
| Ice Production Capacity | Automatic continuous ice cube production and ejection |
| Material | OEM plastic assembly |
| Power Requirements | Must disconnect power before installation (standard refrigerator power supply) |
| Installation Notes | Requires proper alignment of fill tube and secure wiring connections |
| Model Number | WR30X39385 |
Last weekend, I finally decided to replace the icemaker in my GE fridge after it started producing uneven ice cubes and occasional jams. I pulled out the old unit and noticed how straightforward the design of the GE WR30X39385 is—compact, with clear wiring connections and a sturdy fill tube.
Once installed, the new icemaker immediately showed its worth. Ice production was quick, and the cubes ejected smoothly into the bin without any strange noises or jams.
I appreciated how seamlessly it fit into my model, thanks to its compatible design for GE refrigerators like the GDE21EGKTRBB and GNE21FMKTFES.
Handling the unit was simple, especially since I followed the instructions for disconnecting power and defrosting first. The wiring connections felt secure, and the fill tube alignment was straightforward, which is a relief for anyone worried about installation hassles.
After a few days, I noticed a consistent supply of clean, perfectly shaped ice cubes. It’s a small upgrade that makes a big difference during family gatherings or even just daily coffee runs.
The only thing to watch out for is ensuring compatibility with your specific model, as the unit isn’t universal.
Overall, this OEM part feels durable and reliable, providing peace of mind that my fridge’s ice maker will keep up without constant fuss. It’s a smart replacement for anyone needing a dependable, direct-fit icemaker.
What Features Should You Look For in the Best Refrigerator Icemaker?
When searching for the best refrigerator icemaker, consider the following key features:
- Ice Production Rate: A high ice production rate ensures that you have enough ice for your needs, especially during gatherings or hot weather. Look for models that specify their production capacity, measured in pounds per day, to find one that meets your household’s demands.
- Ice Storage Capacity: The storage capacity of the icemaker indicates how much ice it can hold at one time. A larger storage capacity is beneficial for families or individuals who frequently use ice, reducing the need for constant refills and ensuring a steady supply.
- Type of Ice Produced: Different icemakers produce various types of ice, including nugget, cube, or flake ice. Consider what type you prefer for beverages or food preparation, as some styles may be better for specific uses like cocktails or blended drinks.
- Water Filtration System: A built-in water filtration system can significantly improve the quality of the ice by removing impurities and enhancing taste. This feature is crucial if you live in an area with hard water or are concerned about water quality.
- Ease of Use and Maintenance: Look for icemakers that are easy to operate and maintain, with features like an indicator for low ice levels and simple cleaning processes. This ensures that the icemaker remains functional and hygienic over time.
- Energy Efficiency: Energy-efficient icemakers can help reduce your electricity bills while also being better for the environment. Check for Energy Star ratings to identify models that consume less energy while still providing high performance.
- Noise Level: The noise level of the icemaker can be an important consideration, particularly for open-plan living spaces. Look for models that are designed to operate quietly, allowing you to enjoy your home without the distraction of loud ice production.
- Installation Flexibility: Some icemakers require specific installation setups, while others offer more flexibility in placement. Models that can fit under counters or are freestanding may be ideal for different kitchen layouts or needs.
How Do Different Types of Refrigerator Icemakers Compare?
| Type | Ice Production | Size | Features |
|---|---|---|---|
| Built-in | Produces 28-100 lbs of ice per day | Compact, fits into kitchen cabinetry | Convenient, often has a water line connection, Energy efficient (varies by model), Low noise levels, Ice cube size: medium or large, Price range: $300-$1,500 |
| Freestanding | Produces 25-80 lbs of ice per day | Requires more space, portable design | Can be moved easily, often has a larger capacity, Moderate energy efficiency, Moderate noise levels, Ice cube size: small or medium, Price range: $200-$800 |
| Countertop | Produces 26-28 lbs of ice per day | Small, fits on kitchen counters | Quick ice production, easy to use, Generally energy efficient, Higher noise levels, Ice cube size: small, Price range: $100-$300 |
| Under-counter | Produces 30-50 lbs of ice per day | Designed to fit below counters | Space-saving, often designed to match cabinetry, Energy efficient (varies by model), Low to moderate noise levels, Ice cube size: medium or large, Price range: $400-$1,200 |
What Are the Advantages of Built-in vs. Portable Icemakers?
| Advantages | Built-in Icemakers | Portable Icemakers |
|---|---|---|
| Space Efficiency | Designed to fit seamlessly into your kitchen, saving counter space. | Flexible placement, can be used in various locations without installation. |
| Production Capacity | Generally produces larger quantities of ice, suitable for families. | May have lower production rates, ideal for smaller needs. |
| Convenience | Often connected to the water line, providing continuous ice supply. | Requires manual filling, but can be used anywhere with power access. |
| Cost | Higher initial investment but adds value to home. | More affordable, but may lack some features of built-in models. |
| Energy Efficiency | Generally more energy-efficient due to permanent installation and optimized designs. | May consume more energy if used frequently, depending on model. |
| Maintenance Requirements | Requires less frequent maintenance due to permanent setup. | Needs regular cleaning and maintenance due to manual filling. |
| Ice Quality | Produces clear, high-quality ice, often preferred for drinks. | Ice may be cloudy and not as high quality. |
| Portability | Not portable, fixed in one location. | Easily moved and used in different settings. |
How Can a Quality Icemaker Enhance Your Kitchen Experience?
A quality icemaker can significantly improve your kitchen experience by providing convenience, efficiency, and enhanced beverage enjoyment.
- Consistent Ice Production: A quality icemaker offers reliable and consistent ice production, ensuring that you have a steady supply of ice for beverages and entertaining. This eliminates the frustration of running out of ice during gatherings or having to constantly refill ice trays.
- Temperature Control: Many of the best refrigerator icemakers come with advanced temperature control features that help maintain optimal ice quality. This prevents ice from melting too quickly and helps keep your drinks cold longer.
- Variety of Ice Types: High-end icemakers often provide various ice types, such as crushed, cubed, or nugget ice. This versatility allows you to customize your drinks according to your preferences, enhancing your overall beverage experience.
- Space Efficiency: Built-in icemakers save valuable freezer space since they integrate directly into the refrigerator. This design maximizes storage capacity while keeping ice readily available, making it ideal for kitchens with limited space.
- Low Maintenance: Quality icemakers are generally designed for easy maintenance, with features that prevent clogs and reduce the need for frequent cleaning. This convenience allows you to enjoy fresh ice without the hassle of constant upkeep.
- Energy Efficiency: The best refrigerator icemakers are often energy-efficient, meaning they consume less power while still providing ample ice. This not only reduces your energy bills but also contributes to a more sustainable kitchen environment.
- Smart Technology: Some modern icemakers are equipped with smart technology that allows you to monitor and control ice production remotely via apps. This feature adds a layer of convenience, enabling you to ensure you have enough ice for any occasion without being physically present in the kitchen.
What Are the Top Brands Offering the Best Refrigerator Icemakers?
The top brands offering the best refrigerator icemakers are:
- LG: LG is known for its innovative technology and reliable performance in icemakers. Their refrigerators often feature a Smart Diagnosis system that helps troubleshoot issues, and their icemakers are designed for efficiency, producing clear, restaurant-quality ice.
- Samsung: Samsung provides advanced icemaking features with options like dual ice makers and a built-in water filtration system. Their models often include a variety of ice types, such as cubed and crushed ice, catering to diverse consumer preferences.
- Whirlpool: Whirlpool offers robust icemakers that are user-friendly and designed for easy maintenance. Their refrigerators typically have an adaptive defrost system, ensuring ice production remains consistent and preventing jams.
- Frigidaire: Frigidaire is recognized for its affordability and dependable icemaking capabilities. Many of their models feature an ice maker that can produce a significant volume of ice, making them suitable for families and entertaining.
- GE Appliances: GE Appliances incorporates smart technology into their icemakers, allowing users to monitor and control ice production remotely via smartphone apps. Their refrigerators often include features to customize ice size and volume, enhancing user convenience.
- Bosch: Bosch is known for its sleek design and quiet operation, with icemakers that blend seamlessly into kitchen aesthetics. Their models often feature a high-quality ice cube production process, ensuring that ice is not only abundant but also of excellent clarity and texture.
- Maytag: Maytag is synonymous with durability and performance, with icemakers that are built to last. Their refrigerators frequently include a PowerCold feature that quickly chills food and beverages, while the icemaker works efficiently to keep a steady supply of ice.
How Can You Maintain Your Refrigerator Icemaker for Optimal Performance?
To maintain your refrigerator icemaker for optimal performance, consider the following practices:
- Regular Cleaning: Frequent cleaning of the icemaker prevents buildup of ice and residue that can affect performance.
- Check Water Supply Line: Ensure that the water supply line is free from kinks and blockages to guarantee a steady flow of water.
- Monitor Temperature Settings: Keeping the refrigerator and freezer at the recommended temperatures helps the icemaker function efficiently.
- Inspect and Replace Filters: Regularly check and replace water filters according to the manufacturer’s guidelines to ensure clean water is used.
- Defrosting Icemaker: If you notice excessive ice buildup, defrosting the icemaker can restore its functionality and prevent malfunctions.
Regular cleaning of the icemaker not only helps maintain hygiene but also ensures that ice is produced without any strange odors or tastes. It’s advisable to clean the icemaker components and the ice bin to avoid any contaminants.
Checking the water supply line is crucial, as any obstructions can lead to insufficient water reaching the icemaker, resulting in slow production or no ice at all. A clear and properly installed water line will ensure the icemaker receives the right amount of water.
Monitoring temperature settings is important since if the freezer is not cold enough, the icemaker may struggle to produce ice. Keeping the freezer at 0°F (-18°C) is generally recommended for optimal ice production.
Inspecting and replacing filters regularly helps to ensure that the water used for ice is pure and free from impurities. A clogged or dirty filter can affect the taste of the ice and may lead to potential health concerns.
Defrosting the icemaker when you notice excessive ice buildup is essential to maintain its functionality. Ice can block the mechanisms that dispense ice and may cause the unit to malfunction if not addressed in a timely manner.
What Common Problems Do Icemakers Have and How Can You Fix Them?
Common problems that icemakers face include:
- No Ice Production: This issue can occur due to a clogged water line, a malfunctioning water inlet valve, or a faulty icemaker assembly. First, check the water supply to ensure it’s on and flowing properly. If the water line is clear, inspect the water inlet valve for blockages or defects, and if necessary, replace the icemaker unit.
- Ice Buildup: Ice buildup can happen if the icemaker is not cycling properly or if the door is left open too long, causing frost accumulation. To fix this, manually defrost the icemaker and check the door seal for any damage that might be allowing warm air to enter. Ensure that the icemaker is set to the correct temperature to prevent excess frost.
- Low Ice Production: If your icemaker is producing ice but not enough, it could be due to low water pressure or a dirty filter. Check the water supply for sufficient pressure and clean or replace the water filter as needed to ensure optimal flow. Additionally, consider adjusting the ice production setting on the icemaker, if available.
- Dispenser Malfunctions: When the ice dispenser doesn’t work, it might be due to a jammed mechanism or a faulty motor. Inspect the ice chute for any obstructions and clear them if found. If the mechanism is free but the dispenser still doesn’t function, testing or replacing the motor may be necessary.
- Strange Noises: Odd sounds from the icemaker can indicate that the unit is struggling due to ice jams or mechanical issues. Check for any ice clogs or foreign objects causing the noise, and clear them out. If the noises persist, it may be a sign of a failing motor or other internal components that require professional repair.